| Human Molecular Genetics | Pages |
Gene delivery to the epidermis
The Epidermis As A Target Organ
Models For Epidermal Gene Expression
Ex vivo and in vivo epidermal transduction
Transgenic models
Gene Transfer Systems
Viral methods of epidermal gene transfer
Non-viral methods of epidermal gene transfer
Duration of gene expression
Candidate Conditions For A Gene Therapy Approach Via The Epidermis
Inherited skin disorders
Wound healing
Systemic disorders
Cutaneous immunomodulation
Squamous cell carcinoma
Melanoma
Future Developments
Acknowledgements
References
Gene delivery to the epidermis
The epidermis has compelling appeal as a target tissue for gene therapy, due primarily to its accessibility. In vivo gene delivery is feasible, as is monitoring the genetically modified region, and the possibility of surgical removal of aberrant tissue ( The majority of the epidermis is comprised of keratinocytes, of which there are two major compartments, the basal and suprabasal layers. In the human skin, the suprabasal compartment is divided into multiple layers, the stratum spinosum, stratum granulosum and outer stratum corneum. Undifferentiated, proliferating keratinocytes reside in the basal layer. Loss of their proliferative capacity is concomitant with a process of upward movement and terminal differentiation. Keratinocytes can be classified into three types with respect to their clonal proliferative capacity: (i) holoclones or stem cells with extensive growth capacity; (ii) differentiated paraclones with a limited growth capacity; and (iii) intermediate meroclones, which are thought to constitute long lived progenitor cells in vivo ( Keratinocyte terminal differentiation involves the sequential expression of many proteins including keratins, integrins and involucrin. Keratins 5 and 14 are expressed by basal epidermal cells in conjunction with the integrins ( Through the use of the different keratin promoters, keratinocytes have been shown to be amenable to the expression of exogenous genes, such as the coagulation cascade protein Factor IX ( Preliminary keratinocyte gene therapy protocols focused on in vitro epidermal transduction, as primary human keratinocyte cultures are very amenable to genetic modification ( Although the majority of in vivo studies utilise murine epidermis, Hengge et al. recently suggested that this may not be the best model for clinical studies of gene delivery (
Figure
Figure
Transgenic technology is a very powerful system allowing (i) the study of specific gene functions during development, (ii) the production of clinically significant mouse models ( Many techniques have been evaluated for efficient epidermal gene transfer. These approaches may be classified broadly into two distinct categories, viral and non-viral. Retroviruses. Retrovirus-mediated gene transfer was the first delivery system to be used and has been reviewed elsewhere (THE EPIDERMIS AS A TARGET ORGAN
MODELS FOR EPIDERMAL GENE EXPRESSION
Ex vivo and in vivo epidermal transduction
Transgenic models
GENE TRANSFER SYSTEMS
Viral methods of epidermal gene transfer
Non-viral methods of epidermal gene transfer
Methods of epidermal targeting of `naked' DNA by direct penetration in vivo have included intradermal-injection (
Duration of gene expression
In non-viral DNA delivery, gene expression has been found to be transient. In general, the gene product was detected for [sim]7 days (
Incorporating a viral origin of replication into a plasmid vector, thereby allowing episomal plasmid replication, has been shown to increase durability of gene expression (
The use of viral vectors to transfect keratinocyte cell lines has been shown to achieve longer expression patterns although when transplanted, the expression pattern may be more transient (
CANDIDATE CONDITIONS FOR A GENE THERAPY APPROACH VIA THE EPIDERMIS
Inherited skin disorders
Recent progress in molecular biology has allowed a greater understanding of a number of inherited skin diseases, namely the genodermatoses in which keratin mutations have been identified (
Lamellar ichthyosis (LI) is a recessive, X-linked disorder and is associated with a defect in transglutaminase (Tgase1), an enzyme involved in the formation of the cornified epithelium barrier. Choate et al. have shown that in vitro retroviral transduction of primary keratinocytes taken from affected LI patients could restore defective involucrin cross-linking, and when this genetically-modified epidermis was transplanted onto immunodeficient mice the function of the cutaneous barrier was restored (
Xeroderma pigmentosa (XP), an autosomal recessive disorder, is caused by a defect in the XP gene and it has been shown that viral-mediated expression of XP in fibroblasts, complements the DNA repair deficiency of primary skin fibroblasts isolated from these patients (
X-linked ichthyosis is caused by a deficiency in steroid sulphatase (STS) leading to accumulation of cholestrol sulphate and resulting in abnormal scaling skin. Transfection in vitro with the gene encoding STS leads to increased cell maturation and partial correction of the phenotype (
In addition, other skin disorders which may be amenable to treatment in the future are epidermolysis bullosa simplex (EBS) and epidermolytic hyperkeratosis (EHK). Both these disorders are due to mutations in keratin genes. Mutations in basal keratins, K5 and K14, cause the intra-epidermal blistering and collapse of the keratin filament network characteristic of EBS (
The major limitation in treatment of these disorders is their generalised nature, necessitating treatment of the entire skin. In addition, the keratin mutations tend to be dominant and therefore difficult to rectify by supplementive gene therapy due to the possibility of a dominant-negative effect. A focal disease, such as psoriasis, would be more amenable to treatment. It may be feasible to use keratin regulatory elements which are induced in epidermal hyperproliferation (
Wound healing
Applications also encompass acute and chronic wound healing. Severe burns and chronic ulcers have been treated using keratinocyte-containing skin substitutes. These skin substitutes can be enhanced by genetic modification. Exogenous expression of an insulin-like growth factor has been shown to promote keratin growth in vitro and stimulate proliferation in vivo, without altering epidermal differentiation (
Systemic disorders
Gene transfer into primary culture has demonstrated the ability of keratinocytes to express and secrete recombinant proteins, such as the coagulation cascade factor IX (
Studies have strongly suggested that transgenes driven by foreign promoters do not show sustained transgene expressionwhen transplanted in vivo (
There are limitations to this approach, as careful modulation of gene expression is not yet possible. Conversely, it may be possible to use the epidermis as a `metabolic waste disposal unit' for diffusible toxic products in the treatment of conditions such as ornithine transcarbamylase deficiency or other metabolic disorders.
Cutaneous immunomodulation
Although current modes of in vivo gene delivery to the epidermis produce transient, low expression of exogenous gene products, these methods have been successful in stimulating the sensitive immune system present in the epidermis (
Ear-targeted expression of a gene encoding a bacterial antigen was shown by Lai et al. to be effective as a vaccine, producing both a humoral and cytotoxic mediated immune response (
A recent novel approach to vaccination indicated that the transfer of human alpha-1 antitrypsin mRNA directly to the epidermis results in translation of a protein capable of eliciting a humoral immune response. The use of mRNA provides short term gene expression and reduces the possibility of insertional mutagenesis (
This body of genetic vaccination work could have significant implications for the use of epidermal gene expression in the correction of inherited skin disease and systemic disorders, suggesting as it does, that any epidermal-targeted gene product can elicit an immune response. In the clinical setting, this would suggest that diseases due to null mutations are less likely to be amenable to supplementive gene therapy.
Subcutaneous cancer models. As most malignancies arise in immuno-competent patients, tumour cells must develop stratagems for evading the host immune system. As clinically effective immunotherapy is hindered by the toxic effects of systemic delivery, the production of a local anti-tumourigenic immune response is a plausible alternative.Interleukin(IL)-8 is naturally chemotactic for neutrophils. Hengge et al. intra-dermally injected the gene encoding IL-8 into porcine skin and found a functional response within 4 h. IL-8 expressed in the epidermis produced a neutrophil chemotactic response in the underlying dermis equivalent to 30 ng of recombinant IL-8 (
Alternatively, Rakmilevich et al. recently focused on well established primary and metatastic murine tumours using an expression construct encoding the gene for both the p35 and p40 subunits of IL-12, a stimulator of natural killer cells and promoter of cytotoxic T cell maturation (
Squamous cell carcinoma
Squamous cell carcinoma, consisting of transformed keratinocytes, is a common skin malignancy. A recent study by O'Malley et al. showed that by adenoviral-mediated transfer of a sequence encoding the herpes simplex thymidine kinase `suicide' gene, followed by treatment with gancyclovir, regression of squamous head and neck tumours established in nude mice could be achieved (
Williams et al. produced transgenic mice which constitutively expressed B7-1(CD80) on keratinocytes (
Novel tumour-specific adenoviral vectors are also being developed in which the adenoviral E1B protein is deleted. During infection of normal cells this protein binds and inactivates cellular p53, preventing cell death by apoptosis. Adenoviral vectors deleted for E1B can only survive in cells with no functioning p53 protein, as is the case in the majority of human cancer cells. This deletion, therefore, renders the adenovirus tumour-cell specific. These exciting new mutant adenoviral vectors are being used in clinical trials in patients with p53- squamous cell carcinomas of the head and neck (
Melanoma
Due to its accessibility in the skin, melanoma is commonly used as a model for tumour-directed gene therapeutic treatments. A whole spectrum of modalities has been attempted, including direct injection of vaccinia (
FUTURE DEVELOPMENTS
As this review indicates, the epidermis has great potential in a range of gene therapy applications, but there are many limitations to be overcome before its full potential can be realised.
With our present knowledge, and with the new generation of viral vectors being developed, it is evident that the most success to be gained in epidermal gene transfer lies in the local delivery of exogenous gene products for vaccination purposes and in the treatment of cancer. The future is promising in these fields as they require only transient localised gene expression eliciting an attenuated immunological response.
The biggest hurdle in the use of the epidermis as an organ for gene therapy is the lack of a highly efficient in vivo gene transfer method producing high level, prolonged gene expression. There is a need to develop vectors with high efficacy and safety, with low cost and ease of handling. Current transgenic and in vivo studies indicate that our knowledge of epidermal-specific gene regulatory sequences is insufficient to provide gene expression with a systemic therapeutic role. In the future, as research focuses on keratinocyte biology, epidermal-specific gene regulatory sequences and the molecular aspects of disease pathogenesis, it may be possible to attain higher levels of epidermal gene expression or to target expression to specific cell types.
In conclusion, it is evident that gene therapy via the epidermis will complement more conventional therapies and become an accepted clinical treatment modality.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We would like to thank Dr Rosemary Akhurst for her helpful comments on the manuscript and Dr M. Fallowfield for the human skin figure. The work carried out in the authors' laboratory was supported by grants from the Wellcome Trust and Medical Research Council.
REFERENCES
+Present address: Department of Medicine and Therapeutics, Western Infirmary, Glasgow G11 6NT, UK
This page is maintained by OUP admin. Last updated Fri Sep 12 18:09:23 BST 1997. Part of the OUP Journals World Wide Web service. Copyright Oxford University Press, 1997
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
H. Hon, A. Oran, T. Brocker, and J. Jacob B Lymphocytes Participate in Cross-Presentation of Antigen following Gene Gun Vaccination J. Immunol., May 1, 2005; 174(9): 5233 - 5242. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
