| Human Molecular Genetics | Pages |
De novo mutations (GAG deletion) in the DYT1 gene in two non-Jewish patients with early-onset dystonia
Introduction
Results
Clinical evaluation
Molecular analysis
Discussion
Materials And Methods
Patient ascertainment and clinical evaluation
Identification of the GAG deletion
Sequence analysis
Haplotype analysis
Acknowledgements
Abbreviations
References
De novo mutations (GAG deletion) in the DYT1 gene in two non-Jewish patients with early-onset dystonia
INTRODUCTION
Idiopathic torsion dystonia (ITD) is characterized by involuntary twisting, repetitive movements and abnormal postures in the absence of other neurological symptoms or secondary causes (1). Early-onset ITD usually begins in childhood, most commonly starts in a limb and frequently generalizes to other body parts as the disease progresses (2). It follows a pattern of autosomal dominant inheritance with low penetrance of ~30%, including both mild and severe cases (3,4). Early-onset ITD has been estimated to occur at a frequency of 1/160 000 in the general population (5) but is ~5-10 times more prevalent among Ashkenazi Jews (6,7). This may, however, still be an underestimate; based on a recent study in the New York Metropolitan area, the frequency of the GAG deletion in the early-onset ITD gene, DYT1, in Ashkenazim has been calculated to be as high as 1/6000 to 1/2000, or up to 1/6000 affected (8). In a large proportion of Ashkenazi Jewish patients with early-onset dystonia, linkage disequilibrium between the DYT1 gene and a particular haplotype of alleles on chromosome 9q34 implied a founder mutation in this population (9) which probably arose ~350 years ago in Byelorussia or Lithuania (8). Linkage analysis in non-Jewish families with a similar syndrome placed the gene in the same region on chromosome 9q34 as in the Ashkenazi Jewish patients, but all of these families had different haplotypes from the Ashkenazi Jews and from each other (10,11). However, the recent cloning of the DYT1 gene revealed that a single mutation is responsible for the majority of cases of early-onset ITD, regardless of ethnic origin (12). Gene carriers are heterozygous for a unique 3 bp (GAG) deletion in the DYT1 gene which results in the loss of one of a pair of glutamic acid residues in the C-terminal domain of a novel ATP-binding protein (torsinA) (12). Previously, we showed that families with the GAG deletion possessed two different haplotypes within 5 kb of this deletion, suggesting that multiple independent events have given rise to the deletion (12). In support of this notion (i.e. the same mutation arose independently), we here present haplotype analysis and mutation status in two families of non-Jewish origin in which affected individuals manifested a de novo GAG deletion in the DYT1 gene.
RESULTS
Clinical evaluation
Patient 1 was the first to be affected with dystonia in her family. She was a 43-year-old, non-Jewish female patient of Russian origin (Saratov/Volga) in whom dystonia started at 11 years in the left leg. At examination 32 years later, the right arm, both legs and the trunk were affected. Her daughter also developed dystonia which began in the right arm at the age of 10 years and progressed to involve the left arm and the right leg at 25 years, when she was last examined. Patient 2 was the only person with dystonia in his immediate family. Genealogic analysis revealed, however, that he is a seventh degree relative of one of the two Mennonite families with a mixed dystonia phenotype recently linked to chromosome 8 (13) (D. de Leon, personal communication). He was one of three children born to healthy parents of Mennonite origin in Pennsylvania, USA. Patient 2 first presented with dystonia starting in the left foot at the age of 8.5 years. At his last examination, aged 30 years, dystonia had progressed to involve both legs, both arms, the spine and the neck. Patient 2 has no offspring of his own.
Molecular analysis
Haplotype analysis in family 1 shows that individuals II-2 and III-1 have inherited the disease-bearing chromosome from their unaffected mother/grandmother (I-1). The sister (II-3) of the index patient (II-2) has also inherited the same chromosome from her mother (I-1) without being affected. Both individuals I-1 and II-3 do not carry the GAG deletion which has occurred spontaneously in the index patient (II-2) and has been passed on to her daughter (III-1; Fig.
Figure 1. Russian family with de novo GAG deletion. All four individuals share the same boxed chromosome but only the two affected family members (II-2, III-1) carry the GAG deletion (in these individuals the two markers flanking the GAG deletion are indicated by *). The deletion has occurred spontaneously in individual II-2 and has been passed on to her daughter (III-1). Markers typed in a 1 Mb region of chromosome 9q34 and order on the chromosome are: cen-D9S62a, D9S62b, D9S2158, D9S2159, D9S2160, D9S2161, D9S63, D9S2162, D9S2163, ASS-tel (for individual distances see ref. 15). Analysis of PCR products in the DYT1 region of patient 2 (II-1) revealed two distinct bands characteristic of the GAG-deleted and normal alleles (247 and 250 bp, respectively), whereas both parents (I-1 and I-2) showed the normal, single 250 bp fragment (Fig. Figure 2. Mennonite family with de novo GAG deletion. (a) Pedigree of a family with typical early-onset dystonia. Individual II-1 is affected; both parents (I-1 and I-2) are unaffected. (b) Analysis of PCR products in the DYT1 region of individual II-1 reveals two distinct bands (247 and 250 bp, respectively), characteristic of the GAG-deleted and normal alleles. Both parents (I-1 and I-2) show the normal, single 250 bp fragment. (c) Autoradiograph of a sequencing gel demonstrating the GAG deletion on one allele in the patient (II-1) and the normal sequence on both alleles in his parents (I-1 and I-2).
DISCUSSION
Both index patients as well as the daughter of patient 1 presented with typical early-onset ITD (childhood-onset of dystonia in a limb with subsequent generalization), thus displaying the phenotype of the DYT1 founder mutation in the Ashkenazi Jewish population (2). Prior to the detection of the GAG deletion in their DYT1 genes, however, patient 2 and, initially (before manifestation of the disease in her daughter), also patient 1 were considered to have sporadic and `non-genetic' dystonia, although secondary causes could be excluded in both. This supports our prior assertion that apparently non-genetic cases of typical early-onset ITD can indeed be genetic (9), due to the GAG deletion in the DYT1 gene. However, presumed non-genetic cases could be the result of either de novo mutations or the low penetrance of the mutant gene. In both of our patients, it is clear that their sporadic dystonia is due to a de novo GAG deletion in the DYT1 gene.
Although the haplotype presented for family 1 (Fig.
The surprising finding of the same mutation causing dystonia in most cases with typical early onset of the disease, no matter what the ethnic origin, could be explained in two ways: either identical mutations have arisen repeatedly or all cases have inherited the exact same mutation from a common ancestor of ancient lineage (12). Based on epidemiological and haplotype data, the former possibility appears most likely as polymorphisms immediately surrounding the GAG deletion are different in affected individuals of different ethnic origin (12) (N.J. Risch, personal communication and unpublished data). The detection of de novo mutations in two patients of different ethnic origins (non-Jewish Russian and non-Jewish Mennonite Swiss) also clearly proves that the GAG deletion can arise repeatedly and independently in various populations and causes early-onset dystonia.
In order to determine the accurate frequency of new mutations in the DYT1 gene, parents of apparently sporadic patients need to be assessed for the GAG deletion. It is interesting to note that a gene for a mixed dystonia phenotype (DYT6), which recently has been mapped to chromosome 8 in two families of Mennonite origin, is thought to be inherited from a common ancestor (13). Our patient 2 is also of Mennonite origin and, in fact, even a distant relative (seventh degree) of one of the two families carrying the DYT6 gene. His dystonia, however, more closely resembled the phenotype associated with the DYT1 mutation rather than the mixed form of dystonia characteristic for the DYT6 gene, and thus he was tested for the GAG deletion in DYT1. This illustrates that dystonia in patients sharing the same ethnic or even familial background is not necessarily always due to the same mutation.
DYT1 is one of the few genes in which the same recurrent mutation causes a dominantly inherited disease (12). Other examples include hypokalemic periodic paralysis (16), achondroplasia (17) and hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (18). The occurrence of similar or identical mutations is remarkable and most likely due to predilection for mutagenesis at certain `hotspots' of the DNA sequence and/or a distinct phenotype caused only by particular mutations (18). The mutation in the achondroplasia gene and most mutations in the hypertrophic cardiomyopathy gene are single base pair changes that take place at CpG dinucleotides (17,18) which are known to be associated with increased mutation rates (19). However, the reason for the extremely high new mutation rate at the FGFR3 1138 nucleotide in the achondroplasia gene-which renders it the most mutable single nucleotide reported in the entire human genome-remains unclear (17). In all these diseases, it appears that only one or a few types of mutations in the target gene produce a distinct clinical phenotype. Other mutations in these genes are either silent, result in a different phenotypes or are lethal (12,16-18).
Thus far, the GAG deletion in the DYT1 gene is the only mutation we have found in early-onset dystonia patients. This suggests that there is an increased occurrence of this mutation as compared with other types of mutations in this gene. A possible explanation for the high frequency of this particular mutation in the DYT1 gene is suggested by the unusual sequence adjacent to the GAG deletion. The GAG dimer occurs in an imperfect 24 bp tandem repeat bearing a (T)5-(C)4-(A)3 sequence. Direct alignment of these repeats shows 54% identity, whereas deletion of one of the pair of GAGs gives 65% identity (Fig.
Figure 3. DNA sequence around the GAG deletion in the DYT1 gene. (a) Contiguous normal DNA sequence in the fifth exon of the DYT1gene surrounding the GAG deletion (nucleotides 946-951). (b) Alignment of direct tandem repeats in the normal sequence (nucleotides 946-969:970-993) shows identity in 13/24 nucleotides (54%). (c) GAG deletion in the first repeat increases the identity to 13/20 (65%).
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Patient ascertainment and clinical evaluation
Patient 1 was one of 37 patients with classical early-onset ITD (17 of Jewish and 20 of non-Jewish origin) identified through the Neurogenetic Department of the Institute of Neurology in Moscow, Russia, as part of the project `Dystonia in Russia' by the Russian-American NeuroGenetics (RANG) Group. Patient 2 of Mennonite USA background was acquired as part of our genetics research program for evaluation of the GAG deletion in the DYT1 gene.
After giving informed consent, all participants underwent a standardized neurological examination. The diagnosis of early-onset ITD was established according to current criteria (1) and previously published protocols (3,21), including videotaped examinations reviewed by neurologists trained in movement disorders who were blinded to patient status or relationship.
Identification of the GAG deletion
DNA from available family members was extracted from whole blood following standard protocols. We used published primers, 6418 and 6419 (12), for PCR amplification across the critical region of the DYT1 gene. PCR products were resolved in a denaturing 6% polyacrylamide gel and visualized by silver staining (22).
Sequence analysis
Dideoxy cycle sequencing was performed with the Perkin-Elmer AmpliSequence Sequencing kit (Perkin-Elmer) using the specific primer 6419 (12) labeled with [[alpha]-33P]dATP (2000 Ci/mmol; NEN). Direct cycle sequencing (step 1, 95°C 2 min; step 2, 95°C 1 min; step 3, 60°C 1 min; step 4, 72°C 1 min; cycle steps 2-4 ×25; step 5, 4°C 5 min) was performed after enzymatic clean-up with exonuclease I and shrimp alkaline phosphatase (USB) for 15 min at 37°C and 15 min at 85°C.
Haplotype analysis
To establish haplotypes in family 1, several chromosome 9 markers surrounding the GAG deletion were tested (methods according to Research Genetics-http://www.resgen.com and ref. 15; marker heterozygosities given in parentheses): D9S62a (0.44), D9S62b (0.85), D9S2158 (0.78), D9S2159 (0.67), D9S2160 (0.75), D9S2161 (0.79), D9S63 (0.89), D9S2162 (0.76), D9S2163 (0.81) and ASS (0.85). In family 2, a panel of highly polymorphic DNA markers (average heterozygosity 0.83) representing seven different chromosomes was used to verify appropriate inheritance: D1S518 (0.84), D4S1627 (0.81), D7S1808 (0.78), D8S1113 (0.81), D8S1119 (0.80), D9S2161 (0.79), D9S63 (0.89), ASS (0.92), D11S1985 (0.87), D11S4464 (0.78) and D15S817 (0.79). PCR products were analyzed on a LICOR automated sequencer (LICOR) or detected by silver staining (22).
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We thank all patients and family members for participation in this study. This work was supported by the Dystonia Medical Research Foundation (L.O., M.B., X.O.B.) and by the NIH grants NIH/Fogarty RO3-TW00071-91 (M.B., D.d.L.), HG00348 (N.R.) and RO1NS28384-07 (X.O.B). C.K. is a fellow of the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft.
ABBREVIATIONS
DYT1 gene, gene for early-onset torsion dystonia; DYT6 gene, gene for a mixed dystonia phenotype; ITD, idiopathic torsion dystonia.
REFERENCES
This article has been cited by other articles:
This page is run by Oxford University Press, Great Clarendon Street, Oxford OX2 6DP, as part of the OUP Journals
Comments and feedback: www-admin{at}oup.co.uk
Last modification: 8 Jun 1998
Copyright©Oxford University Press, 1998.
![]()
CiteULike
Connotea
Del.icio.us What's this?
![]()
![]()

![]()
![]()
![]()
U. Muller
The monogenic primary dystonias
Brain,
August 1, 2009;
132(8):
2005 - 2025.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
![]()
![]()
![]()

![]()
![]()
![]()
R. E. Goodchild and W. T. Dauer
Mislocalization to the nuclear envelope: An effect of the dystonia-causing torsinA mutation
PNAS,
January 20, 2004;
101(3):
847 - 852.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
![]()
![]()
![]()

![]()
![]()
![]()
K. Grundmann, U. Laubis-Herrmann, I. Bauer, D. Dressler, J. Vollmer-Haase, P. Bauer, M. Stuhrmann, T. Schulte, L. Schols, H. Topka, et al.
Frequency and Phenotypic Variability of the GAG Deletion of the DYT1 Gene in an Unselected Group of Patients With Dystonia
Arch Neurol,
September 1, 2003;
60(9):
1266 - 1270.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
![]()
![]()
![]()

![]()
![]()
![]()
A. H. Nemeth
The genetics of primary dystonias and related disorders
Brain,
April 1, 2002;
125(4):
695 - 721.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
![]()
![]()
![]()

![]()
![]()
![]()
S. Tuffery-Giraud, L. Cavalier, A. Roubertie, C. Guittard, S. Carles, P. Calvas, B. Echenne, P. Coubes, and M. Claustres
No evidence of allelic heterogeneity in the DYT1 gene of European patients with early onset torsion dystonia
J. Med. Genet.,
October 1, 2001;
38
(10):
e35 - e35.
[Full Text]
[PDF]
![]()
![]()
![]()

![]()
![]()
![]()
D. Brassat, A. Camuzat, M. Vidailhet, I. Feki, P. Jedynak, P. Klap, Y. Agid, A. Durr, and A. Brice
Frequency of the DYT1 Mutation in Primary Torsion Dystonia Without Family History
Arch Neurol,
March 1, 2000;
57(3):
333 - 335.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
![]()
This Article ![]()
![]()
Abstract
![]()
FREE Full Text (PDF)
![]()
Alert me when this article is cited
![]()
Alert me if a correction is posted
![]()
Services ![]()
![]()
Email this article to a friend
![]()
Similar articles in this journal
![]()
Similar articles in ISI Web of Science
![]()
Similar articles in PubMed
![]()
Alert me to new issues of the journal
![]()
Add to My Personal Archive
![]()
Download to citation manager
![]()
Search for citing articles in:
ISI Web of Science (35)
![]()
Request Permissions ![]()
Google Scholar ![]()
![]()
Articles by Klein, C.
![]()
Articles by Ozelius, L. J.
![]()
Search for Related Content
![]()
PubMed ![]()
![]()
PubMed Citation
![]()
Articles by Klein, C.
![]()
Articles by Ozelius, L. J.
![]()
Social Bookmarking ![]()
![]()
What's this?